Reducing The Idea of You to Fan Fiction Is Another Example of Dismissing Women’s Art
![]() |
Reducing The Idea of You to Fan Fiction Is Another Example of Dismissing Women’s Art |
Reducing "The Idea of You" to fan fiction is also an example of a rejection of women's art.
Robin Lee's novel Your Ideas tells the story of Solene Marchand, a woman in her forties who finds an unexpected connection with a much younger celebrity. Although the book resonated with many readers, some critics dismissed it as mere fan fiction. This negative attitude is just another example of a larger problem: the tendency to undervalue art created by women.
An accomplished actress and producer in her own right, Lee brings her own experiences and observations to her The Idea of You. Solene's journey of self-discovery goes beyond her unrequited love for celebrities. However, this novel is classified as fan fiction simply because it features a romance with a well-known character.
![]() |
Reducing The Idea of You to Fan Fiction Is Another Example of Dismissing Women’s Art |
![]() |
Reducing The Idea of You to Fan Fiction Is Another Example of Dismissing Women’s Art |
This dismissal is based on double standards. Male writers can explore similar themes of desire and connection without facing the same criticism. While her work is often considered serious or literary, women's literature is relegated to the realm of fantasy and wish fulfillment.
We have to challenge this narrative. The Idea of You is a well-crafted novel that deserves recognition in its own right. Solene's stories explore themes of aging, love, and self-esteem that resonate with readers of all genders.
Here's what we can do.
Support female writers. Read a woman's books, recommend them to others, and celebrate her successes.
Challenge your assumptions: Don't judge a book by its cover (or blurb). Go beyond genre labels and engage with the story itself.
Encourage diverse voices. We advocate for a broader range of stories to be told by women and people from diverse backgrounds.
Breaking down these prejudices can create a space where women's art can be appreciated and valued for its complexity and depth. "The Idea of You" is more than just a celebrity romance. This is a story of a woman finding her voice and her happiness. Let's celebrate this.